AVB Veritas

Case study · District Court Rotterdam · 2024

RGTN Victory Over ACM on Mobile-Number Allocation Policy

RGTN Wholesale Netherlands B.V. successfully challenged two ACM decisions refusing mobile-number allocations. The District Court Rotterdam upheld both appeals, annulled both decisions and required the regulator to decide again. Leonardus Herps led the matter for RGTN and appeared at the court hearing.

A clear litigation win

In ECLI:NL:RBROT:2024:723, the court declared both RGTN appeals well founded, annulled both ACM decisions, ordered ACM to reconsider the objections and awarded RGTN its court fees and legal costs. The regulator could not maintain either refusal on the grounds it had used.

Leonardus Herps’s leadership

Herps led the underlying operator and regulatory strategy and appeared for RGTN at the June 2023 hearing. The case required him to connect the proposed service, commercial chain and technical deployment evidence with the statutory tests governing mobile-number access.

Why the case was unusually complex

  • The applications involved mobile numbers, evidence of timely deployment and relationships across the MNO, MVNE and MVNO chain.
  • The second application concerned a Mobile Global Title for roaming and the relationship among an MNC, IMSI identity, SCCP signalling and ITU-T E.214.
  • The legal dispute required interpretation of Dutch telecommunications law, ACM policy, EU-derived numbering rights and administrative-law rules for renewed applications.
  • The record required the court to distinguish 0970 allocations from the mobile numbers and signalling resources RGTN said its network required.

The decisive legal point

The court held that ACM’s policy impermissibly narrowed the class of parties eligible to apply. A policy requirement for a direct licence or agreement could not replace the statutory question whether proposed use would be realised within one year. RGTN made timely use plausible, and ACM had not rebutted that evidence apart from relying on its policy.

Independent industry reporting

Telecompaper independently reported that the District Court Rotterdam required ACM to reconsider RGTN’s rejected mobile-number application after the appeals succeeded. That reporting corroborates the company-level result. The description of Herps’s leadership role on this page is AVB Veritas’s first-hand account and is not attributed to Telecompaper.

Impact on regulatory policy

The judgment required ACM to reconsider RGTN’s applications within the statutory framework. ACM later undertook a broader modernization and adopted a new general Number Allocation Policy in 2025. Public materials do not establish that this judgment alone caused legislation to change, so the case is presented as an important regulatory-policy precedent rather than as single-handedly changing the Telecommunications Act.

Expertise demonstrated

The victory combines mobile-network identity, MNC and MGT dependencies, roaming, SCCP signalling, operator contracting, numbering scarcity, EU telecom principles and Dutch administrative procedure. This is directly relevant to expert work involving numbering rights, market access and regulatory causation.

Questions from instructing counsel

Frequently asked questions

Did RGTN win the case against ACM?

Yes. The court declared both appeals well founded, annulled both ACM decisions and ordered ACM to reconsider RGTN’s objections.

What was Leonardus Herps’s role?

Herps led the matter for RGTN as its telecommunications executive and appeared for the company at the hearing.

Did the case change Dutch telecom law?

It held that ACM could not add a restriction through policy that did not follow from the Telecommunications Act. ACM later modernized its allocation policy, but the public record does not prove this case alone caused legislation to be amended.

Why does the case show technical expertise?

It connected legal allocation tests with mobile deployment, MNO-MVNE-MVNO relationships, IMSI and MNC identity, Mobile Global Titles, roaming and SCCP signalling.

Public sources

District Court Rotterdam judgment, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2024:723↗Telecompaper: ACM must reconsider rejected RGTN number application↗ACM Number Allocation Policy 2025↗

For counsel

Discuss the technical record.

For conflicts and scope review, send the parties, jurisdiction or docket, issue and deadline. Do not send confidential case files until a secure transfer method is agreed.

Contact Leo Herps ↗