AVB Veritas

Professional standards · Methodology

Expert Methodology and the Proper Scope of Technical Opinion

A useful expert opinion must be technically grounded, reproducible where possible and limited to the expert’s actual knowledge and the evidence supplied. Legal education can improve communication with counsel without turning a technical expert into substitute legal counsel.

Written by Leonardus “Leo” Herps · Published 19 October 2026 · Reviewed 4 November 2026

Define the question before reaching a conclusion

The engagement should identify the disputed system, event, timeframe, parties, asserted duty and available records. Broad conclusions are avoided when the evidence supports only a narrower finding. Assumptions and missing information should be stated rather than silently filled.

Evidence-led methodology

  • Preserve and inventory the relevant records.
  • Reconstruct the technical chronology and system boundaries.
  • Test party assertions against signaling, logs, contracts, configurations and standards.
  • Identify alternative explanations and evidence that could distinguish them.
  • Separate observed fact, technical inference, industry practice and assumption.
  • Explain limitations and revise conclusions when reliable new evidence requires it.

Technical opinion versus legal conclusion

Herps may explain how a network operated, what a record demonstrates, who controlled a technical function, whether conduct aligned with stated industry practice and whether a proposed control could have changed an outcome. Counsel and the tribunal determine the governing law, interpret legal duties and decide ultimate legal questions.

Role of legal education

A law degree helps Herps understand pleadings, burdens, evidentiary disputes and the need to connect an opinion to the question before the tribunal. It does not convert a technical engagement into legal representation, and AVB Veritas does not present him as counsel of record.

Current operator knowledge

Hands-on carrier experience can reveal when an abstract theory does not match routing, numbering, signaling, billing or operational reality. The methodology must still disclose relevant relationships, test the evidence independently and avoid treating personal experience as a substitute for the matter-specific record.

Deliverables

Depending on the engagement, work can include an early case assessment, evidence-gap analysis, technical chronology, focused report, rebuttal analysis, demonstrative explanation, deposition support or testimony subject to the rules and qualification decision of the relevant forum.

Questions from instructing counsel

Frequently asked questions

Does Leonardus Herps give legal advice?

No. He provides technical, operational and industry analysis. Legal advice and ultimate legal conclusions remain with counsel and the deciding forum.

How are assumptions handled?

Material assumptions, missing evidence and resulting limitations should be identified explicitly and tested when additional records become available.

Can an opinion change?

Yes. A reliable expert should revise an opinion when credible new evidence materially changes the technical analysis.

Is testimony guaranteed?

No. Availability to testify is a service capability. Qualification and admissibility are decided for the specific matter by the relevant court, tribunal or arbitration panel.

Public sources

Engagement-specific evidence is reviewed under appropriate confidentiality and scope controls.

For counsel

Discuss the technical record.

For conflicts and scope review, send the parties, jurisdiction or docket, issue and deadline. Do not send confidential case files until a secure transfer method is agreed.

Contact Leo Herps ↗